But! On the plus side we did buy a convertible car seat! It's the Graco MyRide 65 Safe Surround. It was on sale at Target.com and we still had gift cards from our shower so we decided to go ahead and get it, we only paid like $70 out of pocket. Which is pretty good for a car seat that Rear faces until 40 lbs and Forward faces until 65 lbs!
Here she is in it! She falls asleep every time we put her in it! Must be comfy!